The Best Mattress Brands for All Sleepers and Budgets, Tested by Us

Once your mattress has reached the point of no return—meaning it’s worn down and past the warranty date—searching through the best mattress brands to find the right bed can be overwhelming. But fear not. We’ve been testing mattresses from leading retailers for years to help you find the right foundation. To give you a glimpse into our process, we don’t test in a lab or facility. Architectural Digest staffers bring mattresses into our very own bedrooms to use them just like our readers would: in real life.

If you’re not sure where to start on your journey, rest assured. From budget-friendly Amazon beds to mattresses for side sleepers or 100% organic mattresses, there’s a model out there for everyone—and our team has hand selected the picks that boosted our sleep quality here. Find out what we love about these beds, and what (if anything) we were still wanting.

Our Top Picks for the Best Mattress Brands

Best Mattress Brand Overall

Saatva Loom & Leaf Mattress

Specs

1. Delivery: Free shipping, white glove delivery, in-room setup, mattress & foundation removal, $99 fee for returns
2. Sleep Trial: 100 nights
3. Warranty: 15 years

Brand highlights

First and foremost, Saatva’s mattresses are eco-friendly. That’s what attracted me to this mattress brand in the first place. Their mattress lineup includes beds with different firmness levels and styles. While they all seemed like good mattress options, the Loom & Leaf’s promise to cool your body and provide pressure point relief stood out in particular.

How the Mattress Compares

Compared to other mattresses I’ve slept on, I give this mattress an 11 out of 10. I’ve actually been working from bed because it’s the comfiest spot in the house.

Tester: Bailey Berg, contributor

What do you love about this mattress? It’s the most breathable, comfortable mattress I’ve ever tried. There’s also no motion transfer, which makes sleeping through the night easier for the light sleepers out there.

We specifically ordered it because it was supposed to be firm. My partner and I joke about feeling like we’re floating on a sea of ​​comfort. There's little to no say. I think any kind of sleeper—side sleepers, stomach sleepers, and back sleepers alike—would like this supportive pick.

If you could change anything about this mattress, what would it be? Literally nothing comes to mind. Four years on, the Loom & Leaf hasn’t lost its composition. The cooling gel layer still tempers heat—maybe not with quite the same crispness as year one, but enough to keep warm sleepers comfortable through July nights (although, in fairness, the mattress topper we use could be a contributing factor in breathability). Still, the Saatva Loom & Leaf mattress doesn’t feel worn out—if anything it just feels broken in, which is a testament to the high-quality materials and construction (which makes sense, considering Saatva offers a lifetime warranty). It’s still the best mattress either of us have over owned and the next time we buy a mattress, it’ll definitely be a Saatva bed.

Best Smart Mattress Brand

Sleep Number ComfortNext Mattress

Specs

1. Delivery: $150 delivery fee for doorstep delivery, $250 return fee
2. Sleep Trial: 100 nights
3. Warranty: 15 years

Brand highlights

The innovative and technical approach to sleep, mattresses that adjust to the individual, and the ability to track your sleep quality.

Based on comfort, customer service, and quality, I would 100% recommend this mattress and integrated base system. It is genuinely excellent. Aesthetically, the integrated base limits which bed frames you can use it with, it is optimally designed for use with a Sleep Number bed frame which is something to consider if you want a more design-forward frame.

How the Mattress Compares

In comparison to other mattresses I've slept on, I'd give it a 9 out of 10. It's extremely comfortable.

Tester: Lisa Aiken, senior vice president of commerce at Condé Nast

What do you love about this mattress? I appreciate being able to change the firmness of the mattress to suit my requirements via the Sleep Number app, it also automatically adjusts to match your movements while sleeping and lets you track the quality of sleep that you are getting.

If you could change something about this mattress, what would it be? It is difficult to move this mattress, in order to do so you need to unplug the pump, meaning it deflates and needs to be reset via the app. This is time consuming should you wish to move the bed.

The fully adjustable nature of this smart bed means that it can be personalized to your preference with both sides of the bed being independent of each other. As a result, this mattress is exactly the firmness that I want on one side and exactly how my husband prefers on the other. It is easily changed and adjusted on the app which links your phone to the bed via bluetooth so you can adjust at any time to suit your mood.

Editor’s Note: Sleep Number has discontinued the i8 and ushered in a new line of mid-range mattresses. Known as ComfortNext, these hybrid mattresses have many of the same features as the i8, plus improved layers for more pressure relief.

Best Affordable Mattress Brand

Tuft & Needle Original Mattress

Specs

1. Delivery: Free shipping and returns
2. Sleep Trial: 365 nights
3. Warranty: Lifetime warranty

Brand highlights

It’s your classic “bed in a box” mattress, which is always a real treat, if you ask me. When I bought it, I remember wanting an upgrade from my previous spring mattress, but the direct-to-consumer mattresses from all of my favorite podcast ads were still pretty much out of my budget. Tuft & Needle really hit that sweet spot of being a high-quality foam mattress at a ore affordable price.

How the Mattress Compares

My Tuft & Needle Original is my first foam mattress I've slept on consistently, but I can say with certainty that I love it far more than any spring mattress I've slept on. After a certain amount of time, those spring mattresses start to get uneven as the springs wear down from sleeping in the same spot, but after nearly four years, my Tuft & Needle feels as springy and supportive as it did the first night. Also, having a mattress that doesn't squeak or jiggle when my cat comes back from his midnight snack is a real plus for a solid, uninterrupted REM cycle.

Tester: Elise Portale, contributor

What do you love about this mattress? I’m the kind of person who really loves a firmer mattress, but when you deal with an old-school innerspring mattress, the bed simply won’t offer any contouring. My T&N mattress is the perfect blend of a firm foam core that gives me that strong support I prefer and a softer foam outside that does that memory foam thing that is just so delightful.

Every night, I flop into bed with a sigh of relief. Everyone has those days that produce various aches and strains, and when I sleep in this bed, I wake up feeling renewed the next day, like magic.

If you could change something about this mattress, what would it be? I’m one of those hot sleepers, and the unfortunate thing about most all-foam mattresses I’ve tried is that they love to trap heat under you. Sadly, my Tuft & Needle mattress wasn’t really an exception. But these days, the T&N Original Mattress actually does come with cooling gel and graphite inside its layers, so problem solved! The brand has also since come out with a different type of mattress (the Mint—it’s slightly less firm and has three layers of foam, as opposed to the original mattress’s two), as well as a hybrid mattress with foam and springs.

Best More-Than-Mattresses Brand

The Hybrid Mattress by Thuma

Specs

1. Delivery: Free shipping and returns, in-room setup, mattress & foundation removal also complimentary
2. Sleep Trial: 100 nights
3. Warranty: 15 years

Brand highlights

Thuma is perhaps more well-known for their furniture musing—the brand’s bed frame and sectional with Japanese joinery are just two offerings with AD’s stamp of approval. However, this particular mattress caught my eye because of its pressure-relieving promise. I wake up with lower back pain most days and I’ve been searching for a solution for a long time.

How the Mattress Compares

I tend to be a stomach and back sleeper and I’ve found that I still need some additional lumbar support while sleeping. I have been sleeping through the night on this mattress, which is a relatively new thing for me.

Tester: Erika Owen, contributor

What do you love about this mattress? I really like that it doesn't slide around on our bed frame. We have a Floyd bed frame and there isn’t really any traction to hold it in place, so this was a happy surprise!

If you could change anything about this mattress, what would it be? One thing that’s a bit tricky: I’m a plus-size person and I have noticed a lack of edge support on my side of the bed—I wish there was more heft around the edges so I don’t feel quite like I’m going to fall off mid-snooze. I don't think this is a great option for this with serious back pain. But if you’re someone who can fall asleep in any hotel room, this is a solid upgrade pick.

Best Cooling Mattress Brand

Cocoon by Sealy Chill Hybrid Mattress

Specs

1. Delivery: Free shipping and returns
2. Sleep Trial: 100 nights
3. Warranty: 10 years

Brand highlights

The delivery was super simple and fast. The overall setup was even faster! From right out of the box, it rolled out nicely onto the box spring on top of my bed frame. There were no complicated instructions or anything like that. The mattress was ready for sleep that evening.

How the Mattress Compares

I've never slept better. While my previous mattress was on the firmer side, it was not a memory foam or very cool mattress. With the Cocoon Chill Memory Foam mattress, I do not wake up in the middle of the night like I used to, tossing and turning. I also stay sleeping at a comfortable temperature throughout the night.

Tester: Cade Hiser, contributor

What do you love about this mattress? I would give this mattress an 8 out of 10 in terms of overall comfort. It may take some getting used to at first if you are new to firmer mattresses like myself. The memory foam layers adjust to your sleeping position, which makes falling asleep easy.

I can really tell the differenc in my sleep and I wake up feeling refreshed and energized. I used to wake up in the middle of the night and would have so much trouble falling back asleep. With this mattress I wake up significantly less in the middle of the night, and if I do I never have trouble falling back asleep. It really has made sleeping easy!

If you could change anything about this mattress, what would it be? I'm not sure that I would change anything about this mattress. It is exactly what I was looking for.

Best Mattress Brand for Value

WinkBeds The WinkBed

Specs

1. Delivery: Free FedEx delivery, mattress setup or removal for $150, or mattress setup and removal for $225
2. Sleep Trial: 120 nights
3. Warranty: Lifetime

Brand highlights

Because these are only available to purchase online, I really appreciate the customer journey WinkBeds takes you through, comparing Soft to Luxury Firm, Firmer, and Plus. The WinkBeds mattress technology provides strong edge support and wicks away heat, ensuring sleepers have a calm, peaceful night.

How the Mattress Compares

The mattress is a more affordable hybrid option compared to others on the market, plus, for those who are hesitant about purchasing an online mattress, WinkBeds provides a 120-day warranty—that’s a six-month sleep trial period!—which is plenty of time to decide if the money was well spent (in my case, it was!).

Tester: Mark Burka, contributor

What do you love about this mattress? The mattress’s hybrid components truly give you the best of both worlds (supportive coils and soft foam) at a more affordable price than other mattresses I’ve slept on.

If you could change anything about this mattress, what would it be? I would pick the Plus mattress “for heavier people” with the firmest option, now available since I last purchased from WinkBed, knowing the pillow top was going to be as comfy as it is. My partner and I are a same-sex, male-identifying couple and probably would not like to admit that we classify as “heavier people,” but in this case, we do.

How We Tested

We skip sterile lab setups and get a feel for the best mattress brands out there by testing in-house—literally. We bring the beds into our bedrooms and test them for months and even years to give a thorough and thoughtful review for our readers. We also keep the key factors below in mind:

1. Comfort: While the build of a mattress can vary, it should always be comfortable to sleep on. Even though some of our editors prefer firm mattresses and others like plush beds, we assessed the options in our list by how supported we felt, how soft the mattress was to curl up on, and how pressure-relieving the mattresses were night after night.
2. Edge support: Edge control is an important factor to ensure you don’t feel like you’re falling off the bed as you sleep. Editor-favorite mattresses in this list boast strong edges on all sides.
3. Motion control: Motion control is ideal particularly for those who are sharing a bed with a partner or even a pet. The mattresses in this list have strong motion retention to help keep you from waking up from anyone tossing or turning or getting out of bed in the middle of the night.
4. Breathability: Hot sleepers know this all too well, but a mattress that doesn’t have temperature regulating qualities can lead to night sweats—especially when the warmer months roll around every year. Keep an eye out for cooling mattress materials like gel-infused memory foam or natural latex for added relief as you rest.
5. Delivery: Aside from helping you get great rest, a mattress purchase should be as hassle-free as possible. Most leading brands offer free delivery and white glove services, which are helpful notes since mattresses are already a pretty expensive purchase.
6. Warranty: We select mattresses with extensive warranties, usually around the 10-year mark at a minimum, to ensure you’re getting the most out of your mattress before it’s time to call it quits.

FAQs

Which Type of Mattress Is the Best Quality?

There’s no one-size-fits-all approach for the best quality mattress types. It really comes down to your sleep preferences. If you’re a side sleeper, a soft mattress made of high-density memory foam will likely be your best bet to gently cradle your side. Hybrid mattresses are usually best for motion isolation and a balanced feel, especially when it comes to combining sleepers’ ever-changing sleep positions. Innerspring mattresses are ideal for zoned support. To be expected, hot sleepers will want to look for beds with features like a cooling cover to keep them comfortable as they sleep. Lastly, organic beds, like Oeko-Tex-certified latex mattresses, are always at the top of our lists for materials free of harmful substances.

How Much Should I Spend on a Mattress?

There is a wide price range you’ll find for high-quality mattresses, typically anywhere from $300 to upwards of $4,500 for a queen size. And while a steeper price isn't the end all when it comes to the best quality, you will often find more custom features in options with a higher price tag. For example, Sessums’ Ostermoor Bedford mattress (which costs about $4,200 for a queen) features durable, quality materials like thousands of pocketed coils and layers of chemical-free cushioning paired with thoughtful design details like a standout blue-and-white ticking pattern. If you’re not someone who needs all the bells and whistles, you can aim for a lower or mid-price point mattress and still get everything you need for a great night’s sleep.

Do I Need a Box Spring for My Mattress?

It totally depends. Most mattresses today are made to work without a box spring and can be simply placed on the slats of a bed frame. Just be sure to read the fine print about your bed in case there are any specific frame types that you should shop. And, if you’re in need of a few suggestions on that front, check out our editors’ favorite bed frames.

What Kind of Mattress Is Used in Five-Star Hotels?

Our editors travel year-round, taking note of the best hotel mattresses. Through our extensive research, we’ve noticed hybrid mattresses are the most common in five-star hotels and resorts. Promising a Goldilocks feel with both firmness and plushness, these part-foam, part-coil models appeal to the masses. In our opinion, the best one (which you can bring home!) is the Ritz-Carlton Mattress. Each one contains more than 900 individual springs for solid edge support and motion isolation. Even more promising, these mattresses aren't all four-figure splurges. For a hotel-quality bed for a fraction of the price, we also love the Serta Five Star Plush Pillow Top Mattress, an under-$600 pick from a brand you'll find at properties like the renowned Waldorf-Astoria.

Plus, a hotel mattress is only as good as its bedding. Though higher-end brands such as Frette top the list at $1,150 per set, others like Fresh Culture (available on Amazon) start at just $12. "As a travel writer, I sleep on dozens of hotel mattresses every year. But on a recent trip to the Catskills, I did something I've never done before. I climbed into bed during my serene, hillside stay at The Henson, then immediately jumped out to check the tag on the sheets—they were just that soft," writer Liz Provencher shared after sleeping on Fresh Culture sheets.