DigitallyMag
BEAUTY

The Best Mascaras for Older Women Have a Magical Way of Opening Up the Eyes

Admin By Admin
Nov 19, 2026 16 min read 647 views
The Best Mascaras for Older Women Have a Magical Way of Opening Up the Eyes

Time changes everything, including our eyelashes. “As we mature, our lashes can naturally become finer, shorter, and less full, so I’m always looking for the best mascaras for older women to bring back that beautiful definition and volume,” says Melinda Melrose, Dolce & Gabbana Beauty’s global makeup expert.

According to Melrose, those best-in-class mascara formulas add definition, lift, and an elegant flutter to any makeup look, and they’re easy to incorporate into an everyday makeup routine. Her technique? “Start right at the root, gently twist the wall as you sweep upward,” she says. "Really focus on lifting those lashes rather than just coating them with product. The goal is to open up the eyes, not weigh them down."

J. Brandon Correa, YSL Beauty’s national makeup artist, finds that the right mascara can enhance the appearance of each individual lash. “Definition can be just as impactful as volume, especially when working with mature eyes,” he says. “Ultimately, creating beautiful lashes isn’t always about adding more; it’s about understanding how to enhance what is naturally there.”

A light-handed approach is especially flattering on mature women. “Going too bold can weigh the eyes down and make them appear smaller,” celebrity makeup artist Tonya Riner notes. "Use feather-light strokes to avoid applying too much product at once. It is always easier to add than take away." She also advises moving the wand in one direction, working from the base of the lashes to the tips in clean, precise strokes. “This helps the product distribute evenly,” she explains. “Avoid back-and-forth motions, which increase the likelihood of clumps.”

Since sagging skin can make the lashes harder to reach, it also pays to know a few hacks for making application a breeze. To wit: “I take the makeup wand and slightly bend it so it’s more at a 45-degree angle,” says Chicago-based hair and makeup artist Kate Johnson. “This allows you to hold the mascara wand at a more comfortable angle while getting closer to the lash line.” (Bonus: Johnson says there’s no need to straighten the wand out before inserting it back in the tube—it will automatically adjust.) Meanwhile, Riner likes using a wand with “small, tooth-like bristles” for easy, ultra-precise application.

Of course, it doesn't hurt to find a formula that curls, lifts, lengthens, and separates. Ahead, see the mascaras pro makeup artists and Vogue editors recommend for lashes worth batting at any age.

Best Overall: Chanel Inimitable Mascara

Best Overall: Chanel Inimitable Mascara

SHOP NOW

  1. Why We Love It: Available in black and brown-black, Chanel's volumizing, lengthening, and curling formula is a go-to for celebrity makeup artist Nick Barose, whose clients include 87-year-old Jane Fonda—plus some of his own family members. “This is my mom’s favorite mascara,” Barose says. “It has the perfect slim brush and a rich formula that adds drama to the lashes in one, clump-free coat.” Barose notes that small fiber brushes like Chanel’s are ideal for applying mascara, as they coat the lashes evenly and help prevent clumping.
  2. Editor’s Experience: My lashes are long, but they’re definitely not thick or dense with hair. Although I'm not into volumizing formulas every day, this is the one I reach for when I'm looking for a little more oomph, or when I have a full eye makeup look on. I don't find the formula to be heavy, but I still often wipe off the wand right before applying to keep my thinner lashes from getting spidery. —Conçetta Ciarlo, beauty shopping writer
  3. Key Ingredients: Polymers, rice bran wax, beeswax, carnauba wax
  4. Type: Lengthening, curling
  5. Waterproof: No
  6. Additional Features: Ophthalmologist-tested, safe for contact lens wearers
  7. Shades: 2

Best for Sensitive Eyes: Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara

Best for Sensitive Eyes: Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara

SHOP NOW

  1. Why We Love It: Made with 99% naturally-derived ingredients, “This mascara is like the green juice of your makeup bag,” Dionne Phillips, founder of D’Lashes Lash and Wellness Spa in Beverly Hills, previously told Vogue. “It’s clean, nourishing, and surprisingly powerful.” The mascara's dual-sided brush is known to grab every lash—even the baby lashes near the inner corners of the eyes. Plus, the formula is lightweight. "No flaking, no heavy buildup; just lifted, healthy-looking lashes that feel like a natural extension of your own," Phillips said. Because the formula has shea butter and beeswax, it's moisturizing and ideal for those with sensitive eyes. And because it washes off easily with just water, the removal process is also gentle.
  2. Editor’s Experience: I typically coat my lower lashes with a lot of caution (and, frankly, little skill). The lash-grabbing spikes in Ilia’s brush make it easy to coat that bottom layer with smudge-defying precision. Overall, my eyes look so much more awake. —J.B.
  3. Key Ingredients: Arginine, shea butter, beeswax, glycerin, carnauba wax, biotin, and myristoyl pentapeptide-17
  4. Type: Lengthening, lifting, separating
  5. Waterproof: No
  6. Additional Features: 99% naturally derived; ophthalmologist-tested; suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers; resists flaking and smudging for up to 12 hours; removes with warm water
  7. Shades: 2

Best for a Curl: Dior Diorshow Iconic Overcurl Mascara

Best for a Curl: Dior Diorshow Iconic Overcurl Mascara

SHOP NOW

  1. Why We Love It: "This is my favorite mascara overall for more mature eyes," says Aaron Paul, a celebrity makeup artist for clients like Jennifer Tilly, who's 66. "The curling formula lifts the lashes and opens the eyes, while also providing both volume and length. It's also smudge-resistant." Celebrity makeup artist James Molloy is also a fan of the formula, which is enriched with cornflower water to condition eyelashes and soothe irritated eyes. “This gives the lashes the instant volume I like with a silky feel and full bristle brush that helps to lift the lashes,” Molloy previously told Vogue. The classic mascara comes in three colors: Black, brown, and blue.
  2. Key Ingredients: Cornflower water, jojoba esters, cotton nectar
  3. Type: curling
  4. Waterproof: No
  5. Additional Features: Smudge-proof
  6. Shades: 3

Best Chubby Wand: Westman Atelier Eye Want You Mascara

Best Chubby Wand: Westman Atelier Eye Want You Mascara

SHOP NOW

  1. Why We Love It: Westman Atelier's plant-based mascara was also made to deliver maximum volume—a boon for lashes that have lost density over time. Made with nourishing shea butter, the formula also has a botanical wax blend that gives it a creamy, buildable texture, and its pigment, available in black and brown, is made of a vegan ester with intense payoff. Its hourglass-shaped wand has no shortage of fans at Vogue HQ. It lifts, separates, and deposits the pigment perfectly evenly.
  2. Editor’s Experience: The chubby brush lifts and separates in the most natural way—without depositing a ton of mascara on my lashes and then flaking. I can’t help myself from rubbing my eyes throughout the day, and this one I can use worry- and mess-free!”—Talia Abbas, shopping director
  3. Key Ingredients: Carnauba and candelilla wax blend, organic shea butter, plant-derived ester
  4. Type: Buildable, safe for sensitive eyes, flake-free
  5. Waterproof: No
  6. Additional Features: Hourglass-shaped brush, also available as a travel-friendly mini
  7. Shades: 2

Best Volumizing: Charlotte Tilbury Exagger-Eyes Volume Mascara

Best Volumizing: Charlotte Tilbury Exagger-Eyes Volume Mascara

SHOP NOW

  1. Why We Love It: , Charlotte Tilbury’s volumizing mascara has a devotee in DeMann, whose clients mostly fall into the 50-plus age range. “If you want crazy-big, very thick Bambi lashes, this Charlotte Tilbury is a dream,” she says of the mascara most akin to a set of lash extensions. With jojoba waxes to condition the lashes, the mascara also has a special technology called “lash vinyl-black wrap tech,” which is infused with polymers to plump each individual hair. What’s more, it’s resistant to smudging, flaking, and clumping.
  2. Editor’s Experience: Can I just say: I love Charlotte Tilbury’s use of exclamation points. The outer packaging on this boldly promises ‘curl effect!’ and a quote from Charlotte herself, ‘the bigger the better, darling!’ so I was already smiling when I swiped it on. Punctuation aside, the product does deliver—and emphatically (!) I purposely skipped the curler to see if the curved wand does, indeed, create a lift—it does. It also separated my lashes and gave them a fringed-out, fringed effect.” —Jenny Berg, contributor
  3. Key Ingredients: Lash vinyl-black wrap tech, jojoba waxes
  4. Type: Volumizing
  5. Waterproof: No
  6. Additional Features: Smudge-proof, flake-proof, clump-proof, humidity-proof, clinically tested
  7. Shades: 1

Best for Hooded Eyes: Dolce & Gabbana Everful XL 36-Hour Extreme Volume & Lift Mascara

Best for Hooded Eyes: Dolce & Gabbana Everful XL 36-Hour Extreme Volume & Lift Mascara

SHOP NOW

  1. Why We Love It: She may be biased, but Melrose has a soft spot for Dolce & Gabbana's volumizing formula. “What I love about this,” she says, “is that it delivers that gorgeous, lifted, fuller-looking lash effect while allowing you to build the intensity to your preference.” She adds that the formula is enriched with D-panthenol, which helps condition, hydrate, and strengthen lashes; it also features Calabrian Orange, which helps protect lashes against daily wear and tear. As for the helix-shaped brush, “what makes it particularly useful is its ability to catch even those tiny, hard-to-reach lashes, especially around the inner corners,” Melrose says. “When you’re working with hooded eyes, every little lash counts.”
  2. Editor’s Experience: I have hooded eyes, so I perked right up when Melrose mentioned that this helix-shaped brush serves them well. To my delight, I found that she was right—it was a cinch to grab even the teeniest lashes, and the short, spiky bristles really helped with the grip. One coat of this delivered even, clump-free coverage and gave my lashes a noticeable lift, particularly at the outer edges. There was a bit of transfer, so I'd use setting spray right away; then, once it’s locked in, it’s nice for a subtly glam, everyday look. —J.B.
  3. Key Ingredients: Carnauba wax, rice bran wax, castor seed oil, panthenol, argan oil, and Calabrian orange extract
  4. Type: Volumizing, lifting
  5. Waterproof: No; billed as sweatproof
  6. Additional Features: Vegan; glossy finish; refillable packaging; designed to capture short and inner-corner lashes
  7. Shades: 1

Everything You Need to Know

What mascara is best for older women?

For older women, Paul recommends mascaras that offer both volume and length, since lashes can lose density and become shorter as the hair-growth cycle slows down. “Curling mascaras are also great, because they provide lift to the lashes that really helps to open up the eyes,” he says. This is key for older women: Over time, biological factors such as the loss of orbital fat and weakening eyelid muscles can make the eyes appear smaller. As for Bryan, “I tend to prefer lightweight or tubing mascaras,” he says. “I find these types of mascaras don’t put a lot of stress on the eyelashes and still provide ample support and lift.”

What to Look For in a Mascara for Older Women

For older clients, “I like to look for mascaras that contain nutrient-rich ingredients to help condition and treat the lashes over time,” Bryan says. “I personally tend to steer away from waterproof mascaras to avoid them possibly flaking into the eyes.”

According to Paul, customers should also consider wand size. “Smaller, deep-set, and hooded eyes do best with smaller brushes that can reach every lash, even into the corners of the eye, without creating a mess on the eyelids,” he says. “Larger eyes work well with mascaras that have big, fluffy wands.”

What mascara is best for sparse lashes?

For sparse lashes, Paul recommends choosing volumizing mascaras that will build the lash to create the illusion of fullness. “It’s also great to pair a mascara with a primer like Diorshow Maximizer 4D that not only builds up the lash before mascara but also nourishes and strengthens the lashes as you wear it,” he says.

Wand shape comes into play here, too, and Bryan recommends amping up sparse lashes with a mascara that has a smaller brush that’s easy to control. “That way, you can build up volume and length without clumping the sparse hairs together with a larger brush,” he says. Thinning lashes should also consider formulas that feature conditioning ingredients like botanical oils, butters, and waxes which help limit breakage.

What color mascara is best for older women?

According to Paul, the best way to choose a mascara color is to consider one’s overall color intensity. “Brunettes pair well with black mascara, blondes and redheads with brown mascara, and navy works well with gray hair,” he says. He adds that navy mascaras are also ideal for tired eyes on anyone. “They enhance the whites of the eyes to make them appear well-rested and bright,” he says.

Should older women put mascara on the bottom lashes?

Paul says choosing where to place your mascara depends on a few factors. “If you are aiming for a lifted appearance, then only wear mascara on the upper lashes,” he says. “However, if looking more lifted isn’t a concern, then you can also apply mascara to lower lashes.” A hack to get the best of both worlds: apply brown or navy mascara on the lower lashes to add subtle definition. “Then, apply black mascara on the upper lashes to really define and open the eyes,” Paul suggests.

How to remove mascara

The key to removing mascara is to avoid tugging at the eyes. “Eye makeup removal is one of the most overlooked steps in a beauty routine, yet it is absolutely critical to maintaining healthy skin and lashes,” pro makeup artist Lauren D’Amelio Ventre previously said. “After nearly two decades in the beauty industry, working with everyone from brides to celebrities, I’ve seen how improper removal can prematurely age the eye area or lead to irritation, and how the right products can completely transform the skin’s resilience.”

You want to choose something with slip to seamlessly remove water-resistant or long-wearing eyeshadow, eyeliner, or concealer. Start with a micellar water or cleansing oil, then cleanse with your face wash and rinse with warm water.

How We Tested

When we test and review a product, we take a holistic approach to deliver well-rounded product recommendations. First, we lean on Vogue’s vast network of experts—from board-certified dermatologists to celebrity makeup artists—to gain professional acumen on the industry’s standout products, ones these specialists would actually use on their clients. We pair their expertise with our editorial best practices to curate the thoughtful edits you read on our site.

As it relates to mascaras for older women, we selected the best based on the following characteristics: ingredients, wand shape, shade range, mascara type, whether it’s waterproof, and additional features. To do this, we paired our own personal tests of each formula with expert guidance and reviewer insights to determine which we would recommend to you.

SHARE THIS

Did you like our blog?

Comments (0)

All comments are reviewed and approved by an admin before appearing publicly.

No comments yet - be the first to share your thoughts.

Related Articles